Image created with Canva AI
Why This Debate Comes Up Every Year
As soon as the holidays roll in, folks start choosing sides. Some love the nostalgia of a real Christmas tree. Others can’t imagine giving up the convenience of a fake one. Most families land somewhere in the middle, which is why this debate never dies.
Why Real Trees Still Win Hearts
A real tree fills a home with a scent you simply can’t fake. That burst of fresh evergreen when you walk into a room instantly sets the mood. The natural shape, the soft needles, and the classic feel all play into the magic.
The formal tree in the living room is the only live one here, always either a Fraser fir or a Noble fir — the bigger the better. The smell, the texture, the whole experience is part of what makes Christmas feel real.
Why Fake Trees Are the Practical Favorite
Fake trees are easy, reliable, and versatile. You can get them pre-lit, slim, flocked, short, tall — whatever suits your space. They don’t shed, don’t need watering, and stay picture-perfect for the entire season.
That’s why they’re perfect for homes with multiple trees. Three of them stay up every year: one in the dining room, one in the master bedroom, and one upstairs. There might even be another added this season.
Finding Your Perfect Fit
The real question is what fits your life and your traditions. If you enjoy picking out a tree every year and love that natural smell, real is the way to go. If convenience and consistency make the season smoother, a fake one might be your match.
Many people mix both — a grand real tree in the main living area and artificial ones throughout the house. It keeps decorating fun without piling on stress.
Final Thoughts
Real or fake, your Christmas tree becomes the backdrop of the season. It’s where the memories happen, where the gifts pile up, and where the glow feels warmest. The best tree is the one that makes your home feel magical.
Lisa Crow contributed to this article. She is a true crime junkie and lifestyle blogger based in Waco, Texas. Lisa is the Head of Content at Gigi’s Ramblings and Southern Bred True Crime Junkie. She spends her free time traveling when she can and making memories with her large family which consists of six children and fifteen grandchildren.